Latest From the Blog
What does “over-qualified” really mean?
Over Qualified?
photo credit: juhansonin
Mark asks: I would appreciate your assistance on my research into the executive job market for an upcoming article for CIO Magazine. Most executives, managers and senior functional specialists have heard that reply from a hiring manager, recruiter or HR person at least once in their careers. This response is especially frustrating for a job-seeker when they have actually spent the time verifying that their skills and experience do indeed meet the requirements. So, as a hiring manager, have you ever used the term “over-qualified” when in fact the candidate does meet the position’s specifications? And if so, what are some of the reasons why you would do so (eg, candidate’s age, price, reputation, prior history, etc)?
In answer:
I am a recruiter not an HR manager, but have been involved in the hiring process for hundreds of people over the years. The reasons most often I have seen for using an “over qualified” statement are:
- Your compensation requirements exceed the hiring budget
- You will be under employed, quickly dissatisfied, and we will have to hire someone to replace you in a few months
- Favouring an internal candidate as a growth promotion, and have resultantly lowered the job standards to qualify them
Most employers feel that if a candidate is not challenged, he/she will soon be on to to a more challenging career opportunity. There is also fear in this current economic environment that people are taking jobs just to get through the financial crisis, and will quit thereafter.
I have never used the term “over qualified” to remove any one from a hiring process, unless they truly were overqualified. If they are not overqualified but their salary range is out of budget, I am honest and tell them that while they are a strong candidate, our budget cannot support their salary requirement
There are scenario’s where candidates do, and more regularly now, down grade:
- People fed up with dealing with the headaches associated with high positions
- People very willing to start over and just looking for a chance
The risk is lower from the employers point of view with the former of them leaving the company for a better offer, the employer is just concerned that they may lack motivation – these people are normally financially secure. However, they offer great knowledge and experience to advance teams, and it is this aspect they should emphasise in their Cover Letters: I want to work because as well as I want to work for you Mr Employer because
The second group are normally ambitious and have failed on some level. While there is a possibility they might leave for a better position in six months time, employers can manage the risk by motivating them in their present position and showing them a possibility for advancement. In this case employers should always implement a “non-compete” clause, so you are not preparing your next competitor. Candidates in this scenario should always emphasise in their Cover Letters why they want to work for that employer, and why they will remain loyal/show track of in their CV/Resume.
Good Luck!
If you need an interview winning solution, sign-up for our Professional CV service
Sign Up to the Newsletter
Recent Posts
- Flamenco Dancing! Why you are probably better at it than job search….
- LinkedIn: watch out who you connect to…
- LinkedIn Profile Tips
- Sainsburys Jobs
- (Bad) Example of a Job Advert
Categories
- 5 steps to employment
- Admin
- Agency Work
- Aldi Jobs
- Any Job Will Do
- Article
- Asda Jobs
- Assessment Centre
- Background Checks
- Banking Jobs
- Blog
- bristol cv
- British Forces
- candidate
- cardiff cv
- cardiff jobs
- Career
- career change
- career coaching
- career management
- career planning
- career transition
- Careers Advice
- Charity Jobs
- Competencies
- construction jobs
- contract negotiation
- contractors
- cover letter
- credit crunch
- curriculum vitae
- CV Advice
- CV Buzz Words
- CV Examples
- CV format
- CV Help
- CV Interests
- CV Keywords
- CV Personal Statement
- cv security
- CV Template
- CV Template
- CV Template UK
- CV Tips
- CV Writing
- CV Writing Service
- CV Writing UK
- Degree
- Disciplinary Procedure
- discipline
- Dominos Jobs
- Dream Job
- DWP
- economics
- Education
- Employed in one job application
- Employer
- Employment
- Employment Law
- Employment News
- Employment Reference
- europe
- Example of a Job Advert
- executive cv
- Find a Job
- Food Retail Jobs
- Get A Job
- Google CV
- Google Plus
- government jobs
- graduate cv
- Graduate Jobs
- head hunting
- health
- Hiring Manager
- HMRC
- how to make a cv
- How to Write a CV
- I Need A Job
- Immigration
- in job reviews
- Informational Interview
- interim management
- Internship
- IT Jobs
- Job Advert
- Job Advertisement
- Job Application
- Job Application Rejection
- Job Boards
- job hunting
- Job Interview
- Job Interview
- Job Interview Presentation
- Job Interview Questions
- Job Interview Techniques
- job offers
- job relocation
- job search
- Job Search UK
- job seeking
- Job Vacancies
- Jobs Abroad
- jobs board
- Jobs News
- Legal
- LinkedIn Profile Tips
- LinkedIn Recommendation Examples
- Lying on CV
- Marketing
- Marketing Jobs
- Medical Jobs
- Minimum Wage
- Morrisons Jobs
- Networking
- Next Job
- NGO/NFP
- No Experience Jobs
- One Job Application
- online cv
- Personal Profile
- Personal Statement
- PGCE
- Ph.D.
- Pharma Jobs in UK
- Poker Career
- politics
- Professional CV
- Professional CV Writers
- professionalism
- Profile Pictures
- project management
- Psychometric Test
- Qualifications
- recruiters
- recruitment
- Recruitment Process
- redundancy
- references
- regulation
- resume
- resume writing
- retail
- rich & famous
- River island Jobs
- sacked
- Sainsburys Jobs
- salary
- salary negotiation
- Secretary Jobs
- Security Jobs
- Self Employment UK
- Skills Qualifications Experiences
- Social Media
- social networking
- software engineer
- Student Jobs
- sunday thoughts
- Tailoring your CV
- Talent Management
- Technical CV
- Technical Social Magnetic
- Telephone Interview
- Temporary Jobs
- Tesco Jobs
- Training Courses
- tutorial
- UK Unemployment Statistics
- unemployment
- university
- Video
- Video Resume
- visual cv
- Workplace bullying
- Writing a Good CV
Archives
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- November 2011
- October 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- September 2007
- February 2000
- November 1999
- August 1999